Fifteen Minutes Before a Shift Can Become a Major Payroll Problem

If your employees are showing up to work before the official shift time and working, or arguably even engaging in work activities before their paid shift begins, you may have a problem brewing. A recent lawsuit involving a healthcare IT company in the home care space highlights just how big of an issue this can become.

In Cervantes v. Careathome Medical Practice, P.C., d/b/a Vesta Healthcare, the employee alleged that she performed 15–20 minutes of unpaid work before each shift and that this time never made it to the timesheet/payroll and/or that it was “shaved” off her reported work time and she was only paid for “authorized” or scheduled hours.

The Scheduled Start Time Does Not Determine When Paid Work Begins

For nonexempt employees, work the employer requires or knowingly allows generally must be recorded and paid, even if it occurs before the scheduled shift.  And even if the work time was not previously authorized. 

Arriving early is not automatically work time, however, the question is what employees are actually doing and whether those activities must be paid.  In the absence of an employer’s record about this pre-shift work, it becomes challenging to litigate the issue of each of these 15-minute segments of time.

 What Should Employers Do?

  • Identify what happens before the shift. Ask employees and supervisors whether handoffs, patient-record reviews, computer startup, or other job duties occur before paid time begins. Determine which activities must be paid.
  • Make required preparation part of paid time. If employees need 15 minutes to prepare before taking calls or assuming patient responsibilities, build that preparation into the paid schedule.
  • Check your timekeeping settings. Confirm that early punches are not automatically moved to the scheduled start time when employees are working. Review rounding rules and any settings that exclude time outside scheduled hours.
  • Audit timesheet edits. Require a documented reason for changes and preserve the original entry and edit history. Managers should never remove actual work time simply because it was unauthorized or exceeded the schedule.
  • Train supervisors to stop unauthorized work—not withhold pay. Managers must enforce scheduling rules when work occurs. If compensable work has already been performed, address the policy violation separately from paying for that time.
  • Give employees a clear way to report missing time. Have employees review their timesheets, provide a correction process, and prohibit retaliation for reporting unpaid work. An employee’s approval does not excuse missing time the employer knows about.
  • Investigate recurring discrepancies and correct underpayments. Compare a sample of original punches, edited timesheets, and payroll records. Where appropriate, review work-system timestamps to identify possible unrecorded activity, then investigate rather than assuming every login represents work. Correct unpaid wages and any resulting overtime.

If you’re reviewing how employee hours flow into payroll, explore Forework’s payroll and time tracking tools.